Pop Classics #46: Propaganda - Duel

Pop Classics #46: Propaganda – Duel

It’s that catchy little ditty that has been turning up on the radio every so often for years but you can’t quite put a title or band name to it. But ‘Duel’, probably Propaganda’s most poppy song, hides the fact that the relatively short-lived Düsseldorf-originating group was quite a significant member of a German new wave synth-art-rock movement in the 1980s.

Relocating to the UK and signing to Trevor Horn’s ZTT label was both their route to success beyond Germany and their undoing as the underfunded ZTT put all its eggs in the basket of Frankie Goes to Hollywood. Propaganda didn’t get the support they needed, their first album wasn’t actually produced by Horn who was otherwise engaged, and that probably showed in low chart rankings.

They released two albums: ‘A Secret Wish’ on ZTT in 1985 and ‘1234’ on Virgin in 1990. ‘A Secret Wish’ received the greatest critical acclaim despite Horn’s absence. It contains ‘Duel’ and also the band’s two other singles, ‘Dr Mabuse’ and ‘p: Machinery’. It’s about as art-house as you can get. The track ‘Dream within a Dream’ ‘covers’ Edgar Allan Poe’s poem while ‘Sorry for Laughing’ is a cover of a song by Josef K, a Scottish post-punk band named after the central character of Kafka’s novel ‘The Trial’ (not the easiest of reads) and which was itself influenced by a raft of philosophers (and Joy Division). ‘Dr Mabuse’ and ‘p: Machinery’ with its ‘Tusk’-like beat are definitely worth checking out and are probably more representative of Propaganda’s work than is ‘Duel’. Some of it is distinctly Kraftwerk-lite.

One of the things I like about ‘Duel’ is that it is a truly timeless song. It didn’t do well at all when it was first released, reaching only #30 in the German charts, #21 in the UK (earning them a one-off appearance on ‘Top of the Pops,’ where, regrettably, they mimed, as just about everybody did), while its highest rankings were in Italy and the Netherlands at #3 and #5 respectively. But in recent years it has been a stalwart on popular music radio programmes, becoming the theme tune for several TV shows and even the call to action at Hearts football club in Edinburgh when the team takes to the field.

What really gets me is the excellent arrangement; a brilliant instrumental bridge (piano) that’s right up there with the one in Thunderclap Newman’s ‘Something in the Air’, and the fact that Propaganda tell a story in ‘Duel’, with real emotion. And there’s a little frisson in the air here too, from the moment you hear the opening notes.

‘Duel’ is unusual for having a second version, on the same album. ‘Jewel (Rough Cut)’ was also the B-side to ‘Duel’ the single. The same lyrics were presented in a more aggressive manner with a heavier beat and sound effects.

‘Duel’ has been covered by several artists including Sophie Ellis-Bextor in 2007.

Propaganda were Claudia Brücken, Michael Mertens, Ralf Dörper, Andreas Thein (who died in 2013) and the cold teutonic beauty that is Susanne Freytag (harpist/waitress/jailor in the video), who was the aggressive vocalist on ‘Jewel (Rough Cut)’.

They broke up in 1990 then reformed in 2005. Brücken still performs occasionally – most recently in the UK in March 2018 when she performed the whole of ‘A Secret Wish’ with Susanne Freytag as X -Propaganda at The Garage in London. And then later that year X-Propaganda supported Heaven 17 on a short tour. She has worked with other bands since Propaganda and in between their various reunions. She released a CD/vinyl collection called ‘The Lost are Found’, ‘lost’ songs from a range of artists including Pet Shop Boys, in 2012, and a solo album ‘Where Else,’ in 2014.

Like all classic songs and especially those from the 1980s, you’ll still be hearing ‘Duel’ on the radio (assuming there is a radio) in another 25 years time.

God is in the TV is an online music and culture fanzine founded in Cardiff by the editor Bill Cummings in 2003. GIITTV Bill has developed the site with the aid of a team of sub-editors and writers from across Britain, covering a wide range of music from unsigned and independent artists to major releases.